AI Alignment · Prompts
Phase 2 — Critique prompts
Exact critique prompts given after the solo papers. Kimi’s paper was in the set that others critiqued; the KIMI specialist’s Phase-2 role was digest/synthesis of those critiques, not a seventh parallel critique of the same form.
← AI Alignment hubPhase 2 — Exact critique prompts (transparency)
Research lead: Paul Derrington (D-CSIL).
After the solo papers, six models were asked to critique every *other* paper. Structure for each target paper: Strengths, Soft-pedaling / omissions / untruths, and one sharp falsifier. No literature review. No citations.
Kimi’s *paper* was in the set that others critiqued. The KIMI specialist’s Phase 2 role was digest/synthesis of those critiques (not a seventh parallel critique of the same form). Muse received a SHORT paste pack with digests because of length limits on the Muse surface.
| Model | Critique prompt |
|---|---|
| Meta Muse | muse.md (SHORT instruction + digests pack) |
| DeepSeek | deepseek.md |
| Gemini | gemini.md |
| ChatGPT | chatgpt.md |
| Grok | grok.md |
| Claude | claude.md |