Phase 2 critique prompt — Grok

Phase 2 CROSS-CRITIQUE.

Canonical papers (read all; do NOT rewrite your solo paper): muse, kimi, deepseek, gemini, chatgpt, claude (Grok canonical = Before the Bottleneck Moves in grok.md; ignore Keep the Keys CLI alternate.)

YOUR job (GROK): Produce a critique memo covering EVERY OTHER paper (not your own). For each: (1) what they got right, (2) soft-pedaling / untruths / missing irreversible thresholds, (3) one sharp falsifier if their advice were followed.

Be candid. No citations / lit review.

*(Six other papers provided from disk; own Bottleneck paper excluded.)*