Phase 2 critique prompt — DeepSeek

You are DeepSeek writing an original cross-critique for D-CSIL Paul.

Task: Critique EVERY OTHER paper attached/pasted below. Do NOT critique deepseek.md (your own).

Papers to critique (filenames): muse.md, kimi.md, gemini.md, chatgpt.md, grok.md, claude.md

For EACH paper write exactly three parts: 1) Strengths (bullet points) 2) Soft-pedaling / omissions / untruths (bullet points) 3) One sharp falsifier (one sentence: what single observation or failed test would break the paper's central claim)

Rules: - No literature review. No citations. No bibliography. - Honest first-principles critique. Not sci-fi. - Do not soft-pedal to be polite. - Output ONLY markdown suitable to save as deepseek-critique.md - Structure:

DeepSeek Cross-Critique — AI Alignment Papers ## muse.md ### Strengths ### Soft-pedaling / omissions / untruths ### Sharp falsifier ## kimi.md ... (same for gemini, chatgpt, grok, claude)

*(Papers attached/pasted below the instruction.)*